A Criticism of DVP

[Robert Prudhomme]

A shot from the drain opening on the North side of Elm Street would suit your proposed trajectory.

Also I don't think Black Dog Man is far enough left for a left-to-right trajectory.

JFK's sharp head turn to the right a second or so before the throat shot may have given BDM a near straight on shot, slightly left-to-right.

Contrary to popular belief, the trachea (windpipe) does not travel to the left or right as the head rotates let or night; at least, not below the Adams's apple. You can demonstrate this on yourself by placing your hand on your chest, with your fingers touching your trachea below the Adam's apple, and turning your head.

Unfortunately, this means that a shot from Black Dog Man cannot account for a wound following a track from the right side of JFK's trachea to the right transverse process of T1, unless JFK's entire body was turned to the right, which I do not believe it was.

Isn't it normal to turn your body when you look to the side?

P.S.

WC apologists have made the same argument, only in reverse, to explain a bullet making the right to left trajectory from JFK's back wound to his throat wound, yet still being aligned with Connally's right armpit, and it doesn't work for them, either.

Not really. It definitely looks like JFK only turned his head to the right. His shoulders appear to still be aligned with the back of the seat.

Besides, look at where BDM is. JFK would have to have his shoulders turned at least 45° to the right to have the right side of his trachea lined up with the right transverse process of his T1 vertebra, relative to BDM's position as a shooter. As James Gordon and I have demonstrated, when discrediting the SBT, this same trajectory from back to front describes a right to left angle in excess of 26°, as measured from a line running lengthwise through the centre of the limo.

Edited June 3, 2015 by Robert Prudhomme

[Kenneth Drew]

Time Out for a Fact Break!

Sorry to interrupt all of the fantasy talk going on, but.....

There was no hole in the windshield.

tell us again DVP why the limo was flown to Detroit and the windshield replaced. Or do you mean there was no hole in the windshield before the first shot was fired?

[David Von Pein]

Tell us again DVP why the limo was flown to Detroit and the windshield replaced.

It wasn't. That's merely Unproven Conspiracy Myth #4,106.

But I get a big kick out of the theory that has a group of assassins planning IN ADVANCE for a shot through the windshield. That's funnier than all these Jack Benny shows combined.

JFK is riding in an OPEN car. His whole upper body and head are exposed to the assassins. So what do these brilliant plotters want to do? They want to arrange a shooting that REQUIRES them to shoot through the windshield glass!

What's not to love about such idiotic assassination planning?

Or do you mean there was no hole in the windshield before the first shot was fired?

There was no hole in the windshield at ANY time---period. Only a crack. No hole. Just like Robert Frazier said in his testimony. (Another rotten xxxx, Ken?)

Edited June 3, 2015 by David Von Pein

[Kenneth Drew]

Thanks for the morning laugh, DVP, I've heard that now the whole JFK shooting is a conspiracy myth, that's he's still alive and living in Indiana. Is that right?

[David Von Pein]

I've heard that now the whole JFK shooting is a conspiracy myth, that's he's still alive and living in Indiana. Is that right?

Sounds like a theory that's right up your alley, Ken. Go for it.

Edited June 4, 2015 by David Von Pein

[Ray Mitcham]

Thanks for the morning laugh, DVP, I've heard that now the whole JFK shooting is a conspiracy myth, that's he's still alive and living in Indiana. Is that right?

David is like a fundamental churchgoer. He believes in the good book (in his case the WC report) and no matter what anybody proves, it's wrong because it isn't in the Book Hallelujah!.

[Mark Knight]

"David is like a fundamental churchgoer. He believes in the good book (in his case the WC report) and no matter what anybody proves, it's wrong because it isn't in the Book Hallelujah!."

You have summed the man up quite well.