Jump to content
The Education Forum

Judyth Vary Baker to be on Coasttocoastam tomorrow night


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 142
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Just for the record: The whole story is untrue.

I've seen people speculate that maybe it's only partly true, but they're wrong too. She was a good science student, and she worked at Reilly Coffee in the summer of 1963, but she did not have a relationship - ANY relationship, ever - with Oswald, Ferrie, Sherman, Shaw, Ruby, etc. The whole story is untrue.

The same goes for the story she based it on, Haslam's Dr. Mary's Monkey, which is also untrue. He never even comes close to providing evidence for his speculations, not least whether Ferrie and Sherman were even acquainted.

There are important things to consider in the JFK assassination. These claims are not among them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do we know, by the way, how many employees there were at Reilly Coffee Company in the summer of 1963? I say this not because I believe Judyth's story, but because, assuming there were less than a hundred employees at Reilly Coffee Company that summer, it seems probable that she at least KNEW Oswald, if only a little, enough to say, "Hey you!"

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was really pissed off today. KPFA, the local Pacifica listener sponsored radio affiliate, broadcast a long interview with JVB and plugged her books, blogs, website, whatever. If KPFA ever spent any time on the JFK thing or had ever interviewed authors like Bill Simpich, John Newman, David Talbot, etc etc - even Peter Dale Scott, who lives and works nearby, I would accept it. But they haven't and don't. I will call the station and as a supporter for years try to figure out how that decision was made.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm still trying to figure out what happened. Earlier this year, she was wearing a burka, and now she's running around, book signings etc, all out there, in a land that she left out of fear. Wonder what happened that she can spend so much time in the open. She's been here before, but if it's a fear thing, why the exposure?

Might as well move back to the US. It would save her followers having to dish out even more money for plane tickets.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just for the record: The whole story is untrue.

I've seen people speculate that maybe it's only partly true, but they're wrong too. She was a good science student, and she worked at Reilly Coffee in the summer of 1963, but she did not have a relationship - ANY relationship, ever - with Oswald, Ferrie, Sherman, Shaw, Ruby, etc. The whole story is untrue.

The same goes for the story she based it on, Haslam's Dr. Mary's Monkey, which is also untrue. He never even comes close to providing evidence for his speculations, not least whether Ferrie and Sherman were even acquainted.

There are important things to consider in the JFK assassination. These claims are not among them.

THE burns DR. Sherman suffered were only from a regular fire ? (GAAL)

The most fascinating part of this document is that one of the causes of death was "Extensive burns of the right side of body with complete destruction of right upper extremity and right side of thorax and abdomen." ( p. 354, italics added) Haslam takes these bizarre circumstances, especially the extreme temperatures needed to eliminate a large part of her right side and thus lays the ground work for what he sees as the real way she died.

==

Review: Dr. Mary's Monkey

By James DiEugenio

Edited by Steven Gaal
Link to post
Share on other sites

I find it alarming that she's not only been able to push this story, writing multiple books and huckstering for money, but she's now trying to insert herself into the legitimate research community by holding conferences and co-opting a few well-known names.

She has every right to research and fight for the things she believes, but not at the expense of polluting the evidence stream with notional stories.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just for the record: The whole story is untrue.

I've seen people speculate that maybe it's only partly true, but they're wrong too. She was a good science student, and she worked at Reilly Coffee in the summer of 1963, but she did not have a relationship - ANY relationship, ever - with Oswald, Ferrie, Sherman, Shaw, Ruby, etc. The whole story is untrue.

The same goes for the story she based it on, Haslam's Dr. Mary's Monkey, which is also untrue. He never even comes close to providing evidence for his speculations, not least whether Ferrie and Sherman were even acquainted.

There are important things to consider in the JFK assassination. These claims are not among them.

THE burns DR. Sherman suffered were only from a regular fire ? (GAAL)

The most fascinating part of this document is that one of the causes of death was "Extensive burns of the right side of body with complete destruction of right upper extremity and right side of thorax and abdomen." ( p. 354, italics added) Haslam takes these bizarre circumstances, especially the extreme temperatures needed to eliminate a large part of her right side and thus lays the ground work for what he sees as the real way she died.

==

Review: Dr. Mary's Monkey

By James DiEugenio

Respected filmmaker and researcher Steve Tyler has looked into the Sherman case far more deeply, far beyond the needless melodrama and exaggerations of other books, and what he has found will cast this case in a much more realistic light. Her injuries were consistent with the crime scene, and there was no "linear particle accelerator" in New Orleans at the time.

Edited by Stephen Roy
Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow!

The summary is just as much baloney as the book! She's consistently wrong about everything.

Not just 'wrong', deliberately deceptive with ill intent; namely, to bully those who have actual evidence, such as Marina Oswald and, yes, you, Stephen, into submission so that her revisionist Judyth-centered version of events can float forth and find new 'believers'...hopefully, at least some of those tuning in will see through her strategy....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...