Jump to content
The Education Forum

Why do I have to do all of the photo analysis?


Jack White

Recommended Posts

I think you are right, Jerry.

Drommer is afaik as accurate as West

http://i27.photobucket.com/albums/c168/yan...P_ss_HSCA-1.jpg

Edited by John Dolva
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 255
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Discovery Channel's DVD " Murder in Dealey Plaza " featuring Gary Mack puts Nix location here.

GRAPHIC REMOVED.

Incorrect Location fpr Nix.

Chris Davidson was kind enough to have sent me a copy of this DVD about 2-years ago.

This DVD is the scource for ALL the "high resolution frames" which appear in my gallery relating to the following films.

Towner, Hughes, Dorman, Nix, Muchmore, weigman.

John Dolva

You really need to get this DVD :rolleyes:

I have seen some of the fabulous work you can do, and with better resolution Nix & Muchmore Frames, i know the results could be outstanding.

My grattitude to Chris Davidson.

It's because of his generousity that i was able to get the results i have.

Edited by Robin Unger
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jack / Jerry

I beleive this mans " beret style hat" shown in Muchmore to be the shape seen in the bottom half of the Nix Frames.

The man wearing the beret obviously has no respect for people taking films, he walks right in front of Marie Muchmore's camera while she was filming.

He then shows no respect for Orvil Nix, by parking his BIG HEAD right in front of his camera.

Edited by Robin Unger
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jack / Jerry

I beleive this mans " beret style hat" shown in Muchmore to be the shape seen in the bottom half of the Nix Frames.

The man wearing the beret obviously has no respect for people taking films, he walks right in front of Marie Muchmore's camera while she was filming.

He then shows no respect for Orvil Nix, by parking his BIG HEAD right in front of his camera.

How tall was Nix that would be CONSIDERABLY TALLER than this person? Why would

Nix position himself behind this person instead of beside him? How tall is the person

in the beret, and where is he seen in other photos? and it the gray object is a beret,

what is this metallic object on top of the beret? Inquiring minds want to know.

post-667-1265422068_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you are right, Jerry.

Drommer is afaik as accurate as West

http://i27.photobucket.com/albums/c168/yan...P_ss_HSCA-1.jpg

Thanks John,

I appreciate your help. As I'm looking at the photos something has got me puzzled and I want to be sure.

Notice the relationship between the garage divider and the left (north) side of the no parking sign.

Muchmore is obviously further north by a wide margin. However, am I correct that the following two photos establish Altgens further north than Nix?

Am I missing anything?

Jerry

Compare-1.png

Edited by Jerry Logan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Robin, thank you, yes, I agree, the DVD would be helpful. I'll see what I can do.

Jerry, it seems to me that the distance, the elevation, (the panning blur of course, which makes things a bit difficult), and most notably, as you point out, the gap, plus the narrowing of some Nix objects and widening of others, places Altgens somewhere north north west of Nix.

Altgens is sharp enough to use the plat (linked to) to locate Altgens I think. For Nix, there will be a greater error margin because of resolution, blur, so I'd use a couple of frames not too far apart to establish that.

afa Muchmore goes, I think thats a typo, unless you mean her location on the plat. She, imo (based on perspective and parallax discrepancies), started filming roughly where indicated then moved quickly back left to the pedestal to (presumably) use it to stabilise the camera.

Here's a rotated resized Nix with the Altgens (cropped):

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Robin, thank you, yes, I agree, the DVD would be helpful. I'll see what I can do.

Jerry, it seems to me that the distance, the elevation, (the panning blur of course, which makes things a bit difficult), and most notably, as you point out, the gap, plus the narrowing of some Nix objects and widening of others, places Altgens somewhere north north west of Nix.

Altgens is sharp enough to use the plat (linked to) to locate Altgens I think. For Nix, there will be a greater error margin because of resolution, blur, so I'd use a couple of frames not too far apart to establish that.

afa Muchmore goes, I think thats a typo, unless you mean her location on the plat. She, imo (based on perspective and parallax discrepancies), started filming roughly where indicated then moved quickly back left to the pedestal to (presumably) use it to stabilise the camera.

Here's a rotated resized Nix with the Altgens (cropped):

One more for the Mix John.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the same frame as the one you posted Jack. ( No Artifact )

Also, as i understand it NIX was approx 6ft 4" tall according to Gary Mack.

Robin

Gary is wrong

Nix was 6ft 6" or 6ft 7" , he was very tall, just like TOCM

Edited by Dean Hagerman
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the same frame as the one you posted Jack. ( No Artifact )

Also, as i understand it NIX was approx 6ft 4" tall according to Gary Mack.

Robin

Gary is wrong

Nix was 6ft 6" or 6ft 7" , he was very tall, just like TOCM

Can Nix be located in any other photos of the intersection?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the same frame as the one you posted Jack. ( No Artifact )

Also, as i understand it NIX was approx 6ft 4" tall according to Gary Mack.

Robin

Gary is wrong

Nix was 6ft 6" or 6ft 7" , he was very tall, just like TOCM

Can Nix be located in any other photos of the intersection?

Watch Orville Nix interviewed by Mark Lane in Rush to Judgment.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8rdEpZu2QJY...feature=related

Seated at a desk, he appears to be a rather short man.

Jack

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the same frame as the one you posted Jack. ( No Artifact )

Also, as i understand it NIX was approx 6ft 4" tall according to Gary Mack.

WHAT DO YOU MEAN that is the same frame? It quite obviously is NOT the same.

Jack

I think this frame has to be very close jack.

My version of the frame was a little wider than yours, and not quite as tall, but it seems to be a good match. ?

Edited by Robin Unger
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the same frame as the one you posted Jack. ( No Artifact )

Also, as i understand it NIX was approx 6ft 4" tall according to Gary Mack.

WHAT DO YOU MEAN that is the same frame? It quite obviously is NOT the same.

Jack

I think this frame has to be very close jack.

My version of the frame was a little wider than yours, and not quite as tall, but it seems to be a good match. ?

Thanks to Robin, I was able to do a computer analysis of these two frames

which shows very clearly that the gray oval shape was painted in frame

by frame. Thanks, Robin.

Jack

post-667-1265477158_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...