Accusation of Peter Dale Scott being limited hangout operation

[Norman T. Field]

Trolling indeed. 

[Paul Brancato]

If some of you are questioning Calvin’s bonafides I would say that he is relatively new and it seems mostly like he’s catching up and curious.

[Joseph McBride]

I have long considered Peter Dale Scott one of the most

astute historians on the case. He has a long track record

of excellent work with solid documentation. He has

a deep and wide knowledge of US foreign policy

and history and of the assassination. His analysis

is often profound and draws meaningful connections

that have influenced me and other researchers. I don't see

any reason to doubt his bona fides. BTW, I am not a "UCB"
colleague of his. Scott is a professor emeritus of English at UC Berkeley. I live

in Berkeley but teach in the School of Cinema at San Francisco State University. (Speaking

of Calvin, I agree with Paul that we welcome him to the site

with his questions and comments. People who are relatively

new to the case but are seriously interested should not be

driven away or called "trolls.")

Edited June 18, 2021 by Joseph McBride

[Anthony Thorne]

Agree. I didn't detect malice in Calvin's posts, although this one made me raise my eyebrows.

Peter posted links to a podcast this week, noting that he was discussing stuff that he'd kept out of his books but was willing to talk about in an interview. I"ll have to check it out.

[Dan Rice]

Calvin has posted some good stuff.  I don't think he should be accused of trolling.

Edited June 18, 2021 by Dan Rice

[Calvin Ye]

I am not trolling

Edited June 19, 2021 by Calvin Ye