-
Posts
1,199 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by Jonathan Cohen
-
Prayer Man More Than A Fuzzy Picture
Jonathan Cohen replied to Pete Mellor's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
I believe you’re confusing what Hosty did with his interrogation notes with what he did to the note Oswald left at the FBI office, in which he asked Hosty to stop interviewing Marina when he wasn’t home. Hosty’s boss Gordon Shanklin ordered him to destroy the latter, which Hosty then did. -
Pierre Lafitte datebook, 1963
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
It's just non-stop victim mentality from the Coup in Dallas brigade, isn't it? "Acting on behalf of" Jim DiEugenio? On behalf of what? Our top-secret cabal that goes around jealously spying on other Kennedy assassination researchers? Give me a break. -
Pierre Lafitte datebook, 1963
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
The only "wrench" it has thrown is further polluting a subject already rife with ridiculous theories and evidence-free speculation. Promise? -
David Ferrie's voice for the first time!
Jonathan Cohen replied to Vince Palamara's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Aren't there members of Garrison's staff who are still alive and/or would have had in-person interactions with Ferrie? -
Pierre Lafitte datebook, 1963
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Right, like spending the past 20-plus years touting the absolutely laughable and absurd idea that Lee Oswald was part of a secret government doppelganger program along with his imaginary "brother," Harvey, or that virtually every piece of evidence in the Kennedy assassination has been faked or altered .. at least until you need these documents to be authentic to support your beliefs ... -
Pierre Lafitte datebook, 1963
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Truer words have rarely been spoken on this forum. Thanks for at least trying to fight the good fight, Greg. -
Pierre Lafitte datebook, 1963
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Uh, except that it has, by Roland Zavada: https://archive.org/stream/ZavadaReport/Zavada+Report_djvu.txt http://www.jfk-info.com/zavada1.htm It's incredible that you, as someone who seems to believe nearly every major piece of evidence in the case has been falsified or altered, jumps right in with both feet to trumpet the veracity of the "Lafitte datebook." A "coherent reason" would be to make money and insert one's self/selves into the JFK assassination case, which unfortunately has already happened with Judyth Baker. By the way, this forum is hardly made up of "an independent panel of experts" ... -
Oswald's tale - Norman Mailer
Jonathan Cohen replied to Eddy Bainbridge's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
I agree with your assessment of this book, Eddy. Mailer also made a cantankerous and entertaining appearance at the ASK Symposium in Dallas around the time of its release. -
A Problem with "Prayer Man"
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
No, I’m not saying the “crime” would be solved. But a positive ID of Oswald on the steps would by definition prove a conspiracy and as such invalidate every “Oswald did it alone” argument which has persisted since 1963. That may not be enough for you, but it’s perfectly reasonable that it would be enough for many other researchers who have devoted decades to the subject. I truly don’t understand the implication that the research community should be in any way obligated to throw all their chips in on your version of events, particularly given the questionable veracity of the datebook upon which it rests. -
A Problem with "Prayer Man"
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Whether there is or isn't is, to me, irrelevant at this late date. Researchers, and the general public, rightly want DEFINITIVE proof ... not datebooks of unknown authenticity, not absurd theories about Lee Harvey Oswald doppelgangers, not a default position that all of the film and photo evidence from Dealey Plaza has been faked or altered. A definitive determination that Oswald was indeed standing in front of the TSBD during the assassination would end 60 years of debate in one fell swoop. -
A Problem with "Prayer Man"
Jonathan Cohen replied to Leslie Sharp's topic in JFK Assassination Debate
Leslie, do you honestly believe that these so-called "amateur researchers" who had their "attention seized" are now incapable of studying any other aspect of the Kennedy assassination besides the identity of Prayer Man? I also find it a bit odd that you are passing judgment on what topics people "should" be studying. For instance, should Jefferson Morley stop suing the government so he can instead devote his full time and attention to a datebook of unknown authenticity?